The Guide To Best Painter’s Tape

We’ve analyzed 312 reviews of painter’s tapes and compared them side-by-side, scored according to a range of factors.

Below you will find comparison chart.

Top Rated

Rating #1 #2 #3
ProductAmbro Professional
Ambro Professional
GripBlue Multi-Use Blue
GripBlue Multi-Use Blue
X-Fasten Professional Blue 2-Inch
X-Fasten Professional Blue 2-Inch
Price$44
GET BEST PRICE
editors choice
$19
GET BEST PRICE
$13
GET BEST PRICE
Score
100
0
83
100
0
77
100
0
67
Ease Of Use
10
0
8
10
0
6
10
0
7
Ease Of Removal
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
7
Safety
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
6

Painter’s tape, or a stronger version of masking tape which typically comes in a blue color to denote the painter’s variety, is used to mask off various surfaces to keep them from being accidentally painted, sprayed or splashed with the new color which you are applying to the exposed surface. Painter’s tape can be used both indoors and outdoors without affecting the painted surface. It’s a great way to keep all of your painting projects clean, neat, and sharply defined when painting without too much fuss.

How is it used exactly? Often, plastic sheeting or even just plastic trash bags for smaller areas are used to cover a painted surface and your new role of painter’s tape is used to securely (without bubbles or paint peeling) tape this sheeting into place with a perfect seam so that no paint bleeds, drips or in any way gets across the line. Painter’s tape has a slightly more adhesive surface than masking tape to prevent bleeding or bubbles in the tape.

Can you use it for other applications? Certainly. You can put painter’s tape around the lip or edge of a can to keep it perfectly sound and prevent paint from sealing against the surface and needing to be popped off, risking a spill. You can use it to tape off projects, do crafts, create paint stripes, create broken, old-fashioned paint stripes if you rip the tape, and even creating a fireworks effect if you keep taping off in varied directions.

How strong does the tape have to be? All masking tape comes in various levels of tackiness of adhesive, from 1 to 100. Painter’s tape has a stickiness of about 50. Lighter, less adhesive, regular, household masking tape has a stickiness of less than 50 and is usually measured by the number of days you can leave it up without it peeling paint when it comes off.

Product Reviews

Okay, let’s jump right in here…

Ambro Professional Painter’s Tape

Ambro Professional Painter_s Tape

Features: This blue, 2-inch, industrial-looking Ambro tape comes with a 14-day time interval in which you can leave it and then peel it off without leaving any residue. It’s great for a couple of weekends and a week in between in which to paint a full wall, a primer plus paint or get the family involved for a full-scale project like the side of a house.

It’s UV and sunlight-resistant so those 14 days can last outside in the sun, as well. This is a great option for redoing playground equipment, house siding, trimming, molding, plant pots, or various other brightly colored or tastefully hued yard ornaments. It doesn’t peel or crack in any type of weather, and users were particularly pleased by the fact that it creates a watertight seal and also peels off without any leftover residue or lifting anything. Users were impressed by this tape.

Pros
  • Watertight
  • Airtight
  • Peels off easily
Cons
  • Lasted a long time
  • No real downside according to users
Get Best Price

GripBlue Multi-Use Blue Painter’s Tape

GripBlue Multi-Use Blue Painter_s Tape
Features: Now, this particular painter’s tape, the 2-inch GripBlue tape for both professional and household projects, was reviewed extremely well and really did seem to last, according to quite a few users, for the entire 14-day period while coming off easily. Everyone was extremely pleased with this particular tape and there were a lot of repeat customers who only use this brand and this type of painter’s tape in their household and throughout their entire family. That’s a pretty big recommendation right there.

Also, users found it stored well and did not become less tacky or less effective when bulked up in storage and then used a long time later. It stored well and still was effective for quite a long time afterward.

Now, the GripBlue painter’s tape comes with crepe paper backing which allows it to mold more easily, stretch, bend, flex, and be used in all kinds of really interesting ways while also forming a tight seal and coming off easily when you’re done.

Pros
  • Flexible crepe-paper backing
  • Forms tight seal
  • User loved
Cons
  • The flexibility and durability of the crepe paper backing surprised some users
  • Does not tear easily
Get Best Price

CraftsOpoly Colored Paper Masking/Painter’s Tape

CraftsOpoly Colored Paper Masking Painter_s Tape
Features: The great thing about CraftsOpoly’s Colored Paper Tape is that it can be used in place of construction paper for family crafts. In fact, one of the best features of this tape is that it acts like regular painter’s tape but it also can be put to any type of glue or crafting use. It blends in perfectly with paper, cardboard, and crafting supplies of all types. Do you need to keep the tape up in a public location to cover multiple days of painting or securing? It blends in perfectly with any background because it comes in black, brown, lime, violet, cream, cerulean, red, green, orange, and blue. Other colors are included, as well.

Okay, but does it really work for professional paint jobs, too? Users found that color coordinating, organizing, and, particularly, electrical work and male and female electrical plugs was far more effective with this tape. Everyone found it to be functional, easy to peel off, easy to use as labels, and easy to write on. Their only problem seemed to be that they found that bulletin boards and computer equipment worked really well with this, but that two-week paint jobs was more difficult. It had slightly less tack than other painting tapes, but it worked well for painting small jobs.

Pros
  • Comes in many colors
  • Kids use easily
  • Great for writing on and labeling
  • 60 feet of tape per roll
Cons
  • Slightly less adhesive than other painting tapes, but still usable for small projects
  • Needs to be peeled sooner than two weeks
Get Best Price

X-Fasten Professional Blue 2-Inch Painter’s Tape

X-Fasten Professional Blue 2-Inch Painter_s Tape
Features:Out of everything, X-Fasten painting tape is one of the more stable and long-lasting painting tape rolls available. This is particularly strong painter’s tape which is effective on both rough surfaces (like wood grain, plaster, and textured metal) and on delicate surfaces (like glass, porcelain, clay, and brick).

One of users biggest complaints about other tape is that it curls and folds up when you unwind it, but they noticed that this stays straight, true, and easily spread out.

Another one of the biggest features of the X-Fasten tape is that it can stay on a surface up to 60 days without leaving a residue on the surface and without lifting old paint from its location.

One of the users who got the most likes and helpful supportive remarks said that the medium grade adhesive on the tape was perfect for securing their windshield wipers while they go through the car wash. The tape provided by the car wash didn’t work at all, but when they used the X-Fasten blue painter’s tape everything worked perfectly.

Pros
  • Strong, medium-grade adhesive
  • Beautiful against delicate surfaces
  • 60 Days on Surface without Leaving Residue
Cons
  • Plain blue color
  • Single roll
  • A bit more pricey
Get Best Price

ScotchBlue Painter’s Tape

ScotchBlue Painter_s Tape
Features: A great thing about ScotchBlue painter’s tape is that it’s the original painter’s tape in the world. Developed by the original manufacturers of blue painter’s tape, you can rely on the fact that it already has the perfect amount of adhesive and lack of leftover residue built right in.

It comes in a variety of widths which makes home and professional use absolutely perfect for your needs. Users found that, even though it works for glass, plaster ceilings, and delicate surfaces, it also works just as well as the stronger adhesive in automotive tape.

Users found it to be a little more expensive than other painter’s tape, but brand name quality comes with the price and it maintains its integrity in the face of competing painter’s tape. Users found that it works better than frog tape by a pretty large margin and users used it for a large number of applications.

Pros
  • Strong, consistent service across all applications
  • Original Scotch product loved by users
  • Flexible and can be taken off of wet surfaces
Cons
  • No real downside, loved by all
  • A small number of users found it to not be sticky enough
Get Best Price

DoAy Easy Clean Removal Blue Tape

DoAy Easy Clean Removal Blue Tape
Features: After you try the affordable DoAy Easy Clean painter’s tape and see how easy it is to use, it’s only a matter of time before you order some more. This is the cheapest option available and is best used by people who have a lot of messy work that needs to get done and want to use an affordable option to get it done.

Users really enjoyed how this painter’s tape could peel and re-peel and how it did not tear easily, break easily, or crack easily like regular masking tape does. A lot of the work involved with this tape is simply pulling it off and sticking it back on which is the whole point of painter’s tape.

A feature which did not get as good reviews was the inability to pick a custom width for this project. Users would have really liked to see more sizes in the options available.

Now the tape claims to be able to leave for weeks at a time and then comes right off, but none of the users tested this claim so it could not be corroborated.

Pros
  • Cheap to buy
  • Easy to peel and re-peel
  • Good adhesive
Cons
  • Claims to stay for weeks as yet untested
  • No options regarding the width of the tape
Get Best Price

M-Jump Multi-Colored Washi Painter’s Tape

M-Jump Multi-Colored Washi Painter_s Tape
Features: Washi tape is technically patterned and colorful decorative adhesive tape. This M-Jump Multi-Colored Tape comes in bright colors, yes, but it is a lot more powerful than decorative washi tape and the bright, solid colors are friendlier to a wide variety of projects. Use it for electrical wiring, construction pieces, external painting, interior decorating, and crafts with the kids or at the kitchen table.

Users really enjoyed the fact that it sticks well on both carpet and bricks of all types. That made it great for delineating play areas in children’s rooms and for protecting brick surfaces on the exterior of their homes and buildings while working on painting the molding.

The downside to this type of tape is that it can be garish if matched with floor and walls colors which clash with it. Care and attention will need to be given to making sure the colors look well together, so tear off a strip to look at it first. If it looks garish, try another color in the multi-pack.

This was a great pack for kids’ rooms and for kids’ crafting areas. Children put the colorful rolls into their crafting tape dispensers and used it all the time for a wide variety of projects. Teachers got a lot of use out of them for demonstrations in their classrooms.

Pros
  • Bright colors
  • Multi-pack has many options
  • Large rolls
Cons
  • Can be garish if the color is not tested
  • Can be used for painting, but most often used for crafting
Get Best Price

How To Pick The Best Painter’s Tape

Painter’s tape is one of the most versatile and reusable types of tape around. It helps you to do projects, get your painting safely and effectively done, and it sticks and resticks when you need to move it around for small projects.

Let’s examine some of the ways in which you might use painter’s tape and the different circumstances you might find yourself in while using it.

How Do I Start Out Using Painter’s Tape?

First, know that painter’s tape is meant to be airtight and watertight, so in its original form, it is meant to block out paint from some location. However, if you use regular, light adhesive household masking tape, you may find bleed through, dripping, and bubbling of the tape. That’s why it’s so important to always use painter’s tape, signified by its telltale blue color, and use that for any actual paint jobs.

Step 1:

Test the Tape. Find a hidden or easily overlooked area of your wall, ceiling, or your other surface area. Then, place the tape on the surface, rubbing it on the surface hard by gently guiding your fingernails across it.

Leave the tape on for the entire time period you would be working on your project. For example, if your paint job will take two weeks to complete, leave it on for two weeks while you’re preparing your place to paint it. Try to use two pieces of tape. Then, with one piece, lightly pull it away from the surface area. With the other piece, yank it off forcefully.

By doing this, you’ll get a feel for whether the tape takes off paint or leaves a residue behind when you work with it. By using two different methods of removal, you can always see how much friction and suddenness are a part of this process.

Step 2:

Prepare the Work Area. Get your tarp, your plastic wrap, the painter’s tape, the ladder if one is being used, your brushes, paints, and trays in one location. Get out the plastic and tape it in place. Make sure to ALWAYS keep the paint buckets and brushes on a tray, in case of any accidental breaks in the flooring tarp.

Always use plastic sheeting or a tarp on the floor, always put the same side up, folding it side to side and then in quarters and smaller when you are done, so that dirty surface only touches dirty surface. Use appropriate shoes which can take the wear and tear and inevitable paint splatters. If you are using a decorative design, refer to the next step.

Step 3:

Ensure Tape is On Hard. This where you go around all of your taped plastic wrap, look at the sharp line created by your tape, look at where you’ve masked off, and get everything perfect. Run your fingernails over the surface of the painter’s tape to really stick it hard to the surface.

If you are using decorative lines, decorative effects, or are painting along moldings, go ahead and tape these areas up now, after you have secured all of the plastic sheeting. This is a great time to make sure that all of the lines of the edges of the tape are exactly where you want them to be. Pull them away from the surface and carefully reposition them if you need to.

Step 4:

Use Primer and Paint. This is a big step because not everyone knows how important primer is. Think of paint as being the raw pigment material. However, to make it stick to the surface, it needs a glue or a primer to smoothe, prepare, and create a stick situation to which the pigment can cling.

Use a paint and primer in one or prime the entire surface area, let it dry and cure, then paint it. Let this dry and cure, as well. Do not expose your surface to harsh temperatures, extreme temperatures, or wild changes in humidity.

Do You Have Any Project Ideas?

Painter’s tape is really fun for trying out new project ideas. Use deconstructed cardboard boxes for your test surfaces, paint outside, and try everything out without having to do a lot of preparation work. Always wear old, ratty clothes because paint, in the best of times, gets everywhere.

First, paint the entire surface with a single solid coat of one color of paint. Let this dry where it’s not tacky to the touch, anymore. Then, stripe in different, parallel direction with painter’s tape to create a pick-up stick effect. Brush or spray paint a different color on top of this. When you lift the tape, you will see one color with the other color in stripes behind it.

Second, try another paint experiment. Paint the entire surface of cardboard with one color. Let this dry where it’s not tacky to the touch. Then, tape off a frame for the rectangle of cardboard you are using. Make several different frames, covering up the center open area with plastic sheeting. Paint in different colors as you carefully remove each layer of the frames around the edge. This creates a really cool framed picture effect.

Third, finish off your experimentation with textured paints. Create a hollowed out name for yourself by first painting the color you want your name to be all over the cardboard surface. Next, tape off the shape of the letters of your name in the center of the cardboard surface by filling in your name rather than surrounding the letters with tape. Now, get some specialty spray paint (plaster effect, fuzzy metal, etc.) and spray all over the cardboard. When you lift the tape, your name will be hollowed out of the texture and it will be in the color of your choice. So cool!

In conclusion, painter’s tape is fun, versatile, and can inspire wild creativity. Decorate windows, Mason jars, vases, walls, moldings, and crafts by layering paint and tape together. Use tape to square off your house number on the curb. And always remember that painter’s tape is an excellent way to create a highly customized gift for your loved ones. Happy Painting!

Please share
Mark
 

I've been working in professional paint service in Hampton, VA for the last 15 years. So i know a lot about painting and spray painters. With my team we made this site with to help you to understand why some spray painters are better than others, and how to find the best one for your type of job.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: